May 20, 2017 – Dwayne Johnson / Katy Perry (S42 E21)

Segments are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars

HALLELUJAH
Ivanka (Scarlett Johansson) & the rest of team Trump sing “Hallelujah”

— SNL spoofs their own serious Hallelujah cold opening from earlier this season.
— So far, this spoof is doing absolutely nothing for me, and neither are the walk-ons from Trump cabinet members throughout the song.
— Blah, cue the applause break for Scarlett Johansson’s walk-on as Ivanka.
— Okay, I did kinda laugh just now at the brief gag with Trumpwin doing the “Look, no hands” gesture while still “playing” the piano.
STARS: *½


MONOLOGUE
Five-Timers host & Tom Hanks [real] are running for president; Alec Baldwin cameo

— Quite a lot of hosts becoming Five-Timers in these last few months of this season (Scarlett Johansson, Melissa McCarthy, and Dwayne Johnson).
— Random casting of Alex, briefly showing up just to get the “honor” of placing the Five-Timers jacket on Dwayne.
— A funny fake-out with the Five-Timer who Dwayne says will be his presidential running mate turning out to be Tom Hanks instead of Alec.
— A nice charm to this monologue, and a good way to get mileage out of Dwayne and Tom’s beloved public images.
— A decent laugh from Dwayne and Tom each demonstrating how they would handle a national crisis as president/vice president.
STARS: ***


CARTIER FIDGET SPINNER
Cartier’s diamond-encrusted fidget spinner occupies annoying babe (VAB)

— Wonderful to see a new Vanessa Bayer-starring commercial in her final episode.
— This commercial is initially bringing the Kristen Wiig “Red Flag Perfume” commercial to mind, as well as (to a lesser extent) the Ivanka Trump “Complicit” commercial, but this Vanessa ad ends up taking its own turn.
— A very funny and inspired way to spoof the fidget spinner craze from this time.
— As expected, Vanessa is excellent in her performance here, and it’s great to see her play against type once again in these last two seasons of her tenure.
— Beck-as-the-voice-over’s various descriptions of Vanessa are hilarious.
— A great “Because, GOD, the sex is good” punchline.
— Overall, a Vanessa Bayer gem that I had surprisingly forgotten all about until now.
STARS: *****


WRESTLEMANIA PROMO
Koko WatchOut psychologically wrecks Trashyard Mutt again in Wrestlemania promo

— It’s gonna be hard to top the first installment of this, but I can’t complain about this second installment being part of Bobby’s swan song tonight.
— Beck replaces Taran Killam as the announcer from the first installment of this sketch, and they repeat the same running gag of the announcer always being preoccupied with his phone before he suddenly goes into “professional announcer mode”. Just like last time, I don’t care for that running gag, and don’t see why it’s necessary (though it’s certainly not hurting the sketch or anything).
— I love Bobby’s “Ohhhh, nooooooo” when Dwayne brings up Bobby being a Katy Perry fan (even if this whole “Katy Perry fan” portion of this sketch feels to me like SNL pandering to this episode’s musical guest).
— While this installment isn’t quite measuring up to the first installment for me, this is still very funny, and Dwayne’s overly-personal trash talk about Bobby is providing big laughs. I especially love Dwayne’s “You’re the DeVito!” line during the reveal of Dwayne and Bobby being twins.
STARS: ****


ONE VOICE
eighteen additional artists are featured on Big Chris’ (KET) rap song

— Very funny how out-of-hand the increasing number of additional rappers is getting, much to Kenan’s frustration.
— Ha, not only are Colin and Michael involved in this, but they’re playing a rap duo hilariously given the incongruous name “2 Black Guyz”. Colin making a non-Weekend Update appearance rarely fails to be inherently funny.
— This is fun as hell, and I love the very different personality and style each performer gives to their rapper character. This short is also a great way to get the entire cast involved. As I always say, I love seeing a full-cast piece in a season finale (even if, as I also always say, I prefer those full-cast season finale pieces to air at the end of the episode).
— Tom Hanks’ famous David S. Pumpkins character from earlier this season returns in the form of David S. Pimpkins.
STARS: ****½


SCORPIO
(host)’s self-made costume gets more attention than his superhero status

— Meh, the big comedic turn this sketch has taken isn’t doing much for me, despite the likability of Cecily’s performance when she first starts fawning over Dwayne’s sewing skills. This sketch’s type of humor usually isn’t my bag, kinda like I said about that The Boy Is Mine sketch from the Chris Pine episode.
— I do kinda like Dwayne explaining why he prefers not to have a scorpion label on the chest of his costume.
STARS: **


JURASSIC RIVER RAPIDS
Gemma is part of unplanned double date on splashy Universal Studios ride

— Blah. However, at least it makes sense to do this in this episode, given how solid Dwayne was as the boyfriend in the first installment of this sketch. I guess they also realized this is their last opportunity to do this sketch when Vanessa’s in the cast.
— I did get a chuckle from the new addition of Gemma having a pet pig.
— Like last time, Dwayne is fun and natural in this role.
— All of the water that Vanessa keeps getting splashed with throughout this sketch must be a good-natured case of “reverse hazing” for Vanessa’s last show.
STARS: **


XENTREX
(host) uses sketchy male enhancement drug despite side effects

— Dwayne’s various “And he said…” “And I said…”s when relaying the conversation he and his doctor had about the dangerous Xentrex drug are increasingly hilarious.
— A great background visual of Dwayne roughing up Kyle while a long list of the medication’s side effects are shown onscreen.
— I love Dwayne’s very straitlaced, deadpan “Hail Satan” at the end when showing various bad effects of the medication.
STARS: ****½


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Swish Swish”


WEEKEND UPDATE
“Bad Day” accompanies photos of departed Trump administration members

high-strung Dawn Lazarus delivers more meteorological gobbledygook

Drunk Uncle lists things in America that need to be made great again

— Great to see Dawn Lazarus already return after only two episodes, as part of Vanessa’s swan song tonight.
— Like last time, Vanessa is absolutely fantastic at this character’s nonsense-speaking routine. I particularly got a laugh from her smiley, affable delivery of “Hopefully, no goddamn rain.” And, of course, her legendary utterances of “Hap” never fail to kill.
— A good callback to Michael’s Dwayne “The Scissors” Johnson joke from a previous Update.
— As part of Bobby’s swan song, we get our final Drunk Uncle commentary, which is this character’s first appearance since the notorious Donald Trump-hosted episode from a year and a half prior. I’m glad that episode didn’t end up being Drunk Uncle’s final appearance.
— (*groan*) There goes Colin ONCE AGAIN responding to Drunk Uncle’s usual “That’s not me” line with “That’s not anyone.” I’m sure most of you readers know how much that gets on my nerves. Well, this is the last chance for Colin to say that, so…
— Ah, we get an acknowledgment of this being Drunk Uncle’s final appearance, with him asking Colin to do one shot with him “for the road”. However, I wish they did something far more noteworthy than that to make his final appearance special.
— The Russian Roulette bit at the end of Drunk Uncle’s commentary is hilarious.
— Drunk Uncle’s overall commentary was the usual great stuff.
— Surprised this season finale Weekend Update didn’t contain either Colin and Michael’s joke-swapping routine or their “favorite cut-after-dress-rehearsal jokes” routine.
STARS: ****


IN MEMORIAM
a photo of Brad Grey marks his passing
Not included in the copy I’m reviewing of this episode


RKO MOVIE SET
in 1948, star actress (VAB) can’t stop farting while shooting film noir

 

— The “Solomon and Klein – Detectives” window sign in the background (seen in the second above screencap for this sketch) is presumably a reference to SNL writers John Solomon and Rob Klein.
— Hooooooooo, boy. While I’m so happy to see SNL give Vanessa so many showcases in her final episode, and while it’s certainly a novelty seeing Vanessa do a fart sketch, that sure as hell doesn’t mean her doing a fart sketch is a GOOD novelty. I had no desire to ever see Vanessa do a fart sketch, especially not one that feels like a complete rehash of that notoriously horrible Rear Window sketch with January Jones back in season 35. Not to mention this is our second fart sketch of the second half of this season alone (the sit-ups sketch from the Alec Baldwin episode being the first), and the first one was bad enough.
— Speaking of the sit-ups sketch, I’m assuming Steve Higgins is the one providing the fart vocalizations in this RKO sketch, like he did in that sit-ups sketch.
— Well, Higgins is at least managing to get some rare breaks out of Vanessa, which is actually charming in her case, and also a special note to mark her final episode with. My goodwill towards that is the only thing keeping me from completely hating this sketch.
— Lame ending.
STARS: **


INTERNATIONAL MAD SCIENTIST SOCIETY
(host)’s child-molesting robot wins mad scientist evil invention contest

— Ah, yes, here we go…
— An absolutely PRICELESS very dark reveal of Dwayne’s evil invention: a child-molesting robot. Holy hell.
— I love that combination scream/gasp/laughter reaction from SNL’s audience in response to the initial reveal of the child-molesting robot.
— I love Dwayne’s “Robo-ChoMo” name for his child-molesting robot.
— Sasheer’s facial reactions are making me laugh a lot. Our final display of Sasheer’s good straight man skills (which are much better than I had remembered before reviewing these past few seasons).
— Dwayne, on how to build a child-molesting robot: “What you do is, you start by building a regular robot, uh, then you molest it and hope that it continues the cycle.”
— This sketch is easily one of the ballsiest things SNL has ever put on the air, and it absolutely pays off.
— Dwayne, on evilness: “Benito Mussolini used to force-feed people castor oil until they literally died of diarrhea. (pause) I mean, that’s gotta be where the goal posts are, right?”
— At many points in this sketch, Dwayne’s voice and inflections sound VERY Barack Obama-esque (even moreso than his voice usually does).
— Yikes, the random White Castle turn this sketch takes towards the end is freakin’ TERRIBLE. Thankfully, the rest of this sketch is classic enough to not be hurt by that. But still – damn, that was the best way they could end this sketch???
STARS: *****


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest & Migos [real] perform “Bon Appétit”


WINGMAN
while being (host)’s wingman, bartender (BEB) adds himself to hookups

— A big laugh from the first threesome reveal.
— Beck is solid in this lead role and has a pretty good amount of funny lines.
— A very funny sudden appearance from Bobby as “Carlos”, our final display of Bobby’s great ability to steal a sketch with a simple walk-on.
STARS: ***½


SENIOR SKIT
high school seniors (BEB), (KYM), (BOM), (VAB) perform valedictory sketch

— (*sigh*) Welp, this is it, folks. Bobby and Vanessa’s final sketch as cast members.
— Man, when Bobby says, in a sad, emotional manner, “Now it’s coming to an end” in regards to the crazy ride that his and his classmates’ four years of high school have been, you can tell that 1) there’s a lot of reality subtext in that line, given his and Vanessa’s SNL departures, and 2) his sad, emotional delivery of that line was NOT acting. His delivery of that line is heart-breaking.
— A very good running gag with a deadpan Leslie as the lunchlady whenever her cooking gets slammed.
— This sketch probably isn’t anything special on paper, but there’s a nice charm to it when seeing it played out, obviously helped by the fact that this is Bobby and Vanessa’s sendoff. Too bad SNL didn’t put Sasheer in this as one of the students performing this play. She and SNL apparently knew at this time that she was leaving, as an SNL fan once mentioned back at this time that there were photos online (can’t remember where) of Bobby, Vanessa, and Sasheer each being lifted in the air by their castmates at the end of this episode’s goodnights (not seen in the televised version of this episode’s goodnights, unfortunately).
— The ending of this sketch seemed like it got cut a little short due to the show running long. That also probably explains why this sketch in general had a rushed vibe.
STARS: ***½


GOODNIGHTS

— Interesting seeing the audience actually give a standing ovation in these season finale goodnights.


IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS
— A fitting end to such a good, memorable season. Much like this season itself, while this episode certainly had some lowlights, they were far outnumbered by some great highlights, including two five-star pieces (Cartier Fidget Spinner and International Mad Scientist Society). Dwayne Johnson did his usual fantastic hosting job, and his hosting skills & comforting presence were particularly welcome in a season finale.


MY PERSONAL CHOICE OF “BEST OF” MOMENTS FOR THIS EPISODE, REPRESENTED WITH SCREENCAPS


RATED SEGMENTS RANKED FROM BEST TO WORST
International Mad Scientist Society
Cartier Fidget Spinner
One Voice / Xentrex (tie)
Wrestlemania Promo
Weekend Update
Wingman
Senior Skit
Monologue
Jurassic River Rapids
Scorpio
RKO Movie Set
Hallelujah


HOW THIS EPISODE STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING ONE (Melissa McCarthy)
a slight step up


MY PERSONAL CHOICE OF “BEST OF” MOMENTS FOR THIS ENTIRE SEASON, REPRESENTED WITH SCREENCAPS, IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER

 


HOW THIS OVERALL SEASON STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING SEASON (2015-16)
a slight step up


My full set of screencaps for this episode is here


TOMORROW
Season 43 begins, with host Ryan Gosling, and three new additions to the cast

October 12, 2013 – Bruce Willis / Katy Perry (S39 E3)

Segments are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars

NASA SHUTDOWN
government shutdown impacts NASA & Gravity astronauts (TAK) & (CES)

— Pretty funny non-verbal reaction Kenan’s night janitor character initially has to Taran and Cecily’s panicked call. I also like him answering that call by innocently asking a light-hearted “Yello?”
— SNL gets more good mileage out of the government shutdown.
— A good laugh from Taran’s delivery of “Why don’t we make this asphyxiation…an erotic one?”
STARS: ***½


MONOLOGUE
BOM plays harmonica poorly & fancies himself to be like host’s son

— Wasn’t too crazy about Bruce Willis’ joke about six Die Hards. His delivery of it was pretty awkward, which already sets a bad tone for how his hosting performance will go in tonight’s episode.
— Thank god Bobby has shown up to offer some much-needed comic relief.
— Despite the humor Bobby’s bringing to this, the interplay between him and Bruce feels kinda weird, thanks to Bruce’s lack of ANY kind of believable chemistry with Bobby.
— Much like Bruce’s last monologue from all the way back in 1989, we get a display of his harmonica-playing skills. Some entertaining tunes from him here.
— Love the gag with Bobby repeatedly breathing in and out of his harmonica because he’s out of breath and needs his inhaler.
STARS: **½


24-HOUR ENERGY FOR DATING ACTRESSES
harrowed boyfriends cope by drinking 24-Hour Energy For Dating Actresses

— Funny reveal of this being an energy drink ad for men who are dating actresses. A relatable premise, though I’m sure this resonates more with people who can relate to this more than I can.
— Cecily’s angry outburst is giving me some good laughs.
— Another amusing non-verbal reaction from Kenan tonight, this time when seeing his girlfriend Cecily do a physical romantic scene with a shirtless Jay.
— Good ending about an energy drink for women dating hacky comedians.
STARS: ***½


BLACK OPS
(host)’s unrealistically-cinematic attack plan sways fellow Navy SEALs

— A funny blunt, short, and to-the-point clarification from Beck after Bruce’s very long-winded and detailed first answer.
— I have mixed feelings on this sketch so far. Actually, the premise isn’t bad, and the cast members are doing good work. I think my problem with this sketch is Bruce’s delivery, especially how mumbly and low-talky he occasionally gets. John Milhiser would later disclose in an interview (I can’t remember who interviewed him) that, during the table read for this episode, people in the room called attention to Bruce’s habit of mumbling and low-talking his way through his line readings, and asked him to speak louder and more clearly. In response, Bruce nodded his head and gave a thumbs-up gesture, only to IMMEDIATELY continue mumbling and low-talking his way through his line readings. Looks like that habit of his has carried over into parts of the live show, as this sketch is showing.
— I’m loving Bobby’s over-excited reactions to Bruce’s details in his action movie-like plan.
STARS: **


THE OL’ BARBERSHOP
(host)’s unembellished anecdotes fall flat compared to fellow barbers’

— Very fun performances and delivery from Kenan and Jay, the latter of whom seems to intentionally be doing an impression of Eddie Murphy’s barber character from Coming To America.
— Bruce is wearing a wig that seems to be an intentional replica of his real hairstyle from his previous hosting stint in 1989 (side-by-side comparison below).

   

— The main comedic conceit of this sketch with Bruce’s weird, offbeat stories isn’t bad, but once AGAIN tonight, I am not caring much for Bruce’s delivery. Kenan and Jay’s side characters are amusing me far more than Bruce’s main character is.
— What the hell? Bruce completely fucked up the whole ending. He missed his cue to remove Bobby’s barber cape and started making his exit a little too early, forcing Bobby himself to awkwardly start removing the cape, only for Bruce to finally realize his mistake and come over to help Bobby remove the cape, revealing an orange prison jumpsuit that Bobby’s randomly wearing under the cape. That prison jumpsuit reveal, which was supposed to get a big laugh from the audience, falls completely flat and is met with confused silence from the audience because Bruce screwed up the timing it so damn badly. Then Bruce proceeds to completely botch his timing of his “It was Sheryl Crow” reveal right as he makes his scripted exit, leading to awkward silence before Kenan and Jay keep the ending of the sketch going. Man, Bruce has been a trainwreck-y host tonight so far.
STARS: **


BOY DANCE PARTY
regular guys bust a move when the ladies are away

— Oh, I’m eager to re-watch this right now. I remember this music video being a blast when I last saw it back when it originally aired 7 years ago.
— Yeah, so far, this is absolutely holding up for me. I’m loving this. The catchy music, the visuals, the gags, the performances…everything about this is working for me.
— Great bit with Taran continuing to spray Bobby with silly string while all the men are holding in a frozen pose when Vanessa briefly comes back in the apartment to get her purse.
— The “Shake that sack” part is priceless.
— Even the stiff-in-tonight’s-episode Bruce Willis is coming off silly and loose here, for once tonight. And, if you know me, you’ll know I appreciate Bruce’s Three Stooges reference with him doing Curly’s spinning-around-on the-floor routine at one point.
— A solid yell from Vanessa at the end.
STARS: ****½


THE LADY GAGA SHOW
Lady Gaga (VAB) interviews Michael Kors (host) & Penelope Cruz (KAM)

— Wait, Vanessa as Lady Gaga?!? Ooooookay, unexpected casting there.
— Yeesh. I love Vanessa as much as the next SNL fan, but in this sketch so far, her Lady Gaga impression is NOT working, especially not that voice she’s using, which is all wrong for this role.
— Oh, and it goes without saying how I’m not crazy about seeing yet another display of one of SNL’s laziest, most overrelied-upon crutches: a celebrity-hosted talk show sketch. Now that I think of it, however, it does feel like SNL has thankfully been cutting back on the number of celebrity-hosted talk show sketches the last few seasons prior to this.
— Oh…my…god at that insane, over-the-top, high-pitched, shrieky delivery Bruce is using here, basically playing a caricature of a caricature of a caricature of a gay stereotype. (From what I’ve heard from some other SNL fans, the real Michael Kors, who Bruce is playing in this sketch, sounds NOTHING like this.) It’s almost like Bruce heard my complaint about how stiff most of his performances in this episode have been, and is now overcompensating for that by going the opposite end of the extreme, giving a super over-the-top, animated performance in this sketch. Whatever he’s trying to do here, I can’t say it’s working for me.
— The gag with Kate’s Penelope Cruz mispronouncing shampoo ingredients in her thick accent is just repeating what SNL did the last time Kate’s Penelope Cruz appeared, which was actually in Kate’s very first episode. I enjoyed that Penelope-Cruz-mispronouncing-ingredients gag the first time, especially since it was Kate’s very first big showcase on SNL, but I didn’t need a reprisal of it being questionably shoehorned into this completely unrelated Lady Gaga Show sketch.
— Aidy’s reaction to her Gaga-style makeover is hilarious, and is the only real positive I can find in this bad sketch (aside from a chuckle or two I got from Taran’s DJ character).
STARS: *½


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Roar”


WEEKEND UPDATE
Senate chaplain Barry Black (KET) wishes harm on obstructionist Congress

BRW gives the cautionary tales behind his three ill-advised tattoos

— Yeesh, Seth and Cecily’s jokes tonight are pretty awful so far.
— Good performance from Kenan, but I’m not all that crazy about the material in his commentary so far, aside from a laugh I got from the detail of his comment about beating someone with a pillowcase full of Skittles.
— Okay, Kenan’s commentary is getting better as it goes on.
— Speaking of getting better as it goes on, Seth and Cecily’s Update jokes are somewhat improving after a rough first two minutes. I especially liked Seth’s George Clooney joke. Cecily’s general Update delivery, however, still isn’t working much for me, aside from her comically-sleazy delivery during the punchline of her joke about sexual harassment.
— I like the return of the old recurring bit where Seth (and sometimes Amy Poehler, when she was his co-anchor) tell the same Update joke multiple times in a row, with a different punchline each time. Prior to tonight’s episode, Seth hadn’t done this bit in years.
— Cecily, in one of her and Seth’s multiple Jenner divorce jokes: “’It’s sad, but I’m excited to start my new life as a single middle-aged woman’, said Bruce.” The fact that the audience laughs hysterically at that joke just goes to show you how much society and standards have changed in the mere seven years since this episode originally aired.
— Great to see Brooks getting his own Update commentary as himself, especially given how the tradition of cast members doing stand-up-style Update commentaries as themselves had long been abandoned prior to this.
— Brooks is pretty solid here. He’s displaying good self-deprecating humor regarding the dumbness of his tattoos, and he’s coming off likable and relatable. It should’ve become a common occurrence for him to do Update commentaries as himself this season, but we end up only seeing him do one more, and it’s not until towards the end of this season.
STARS: **½


ARMAGEDDON
Kirby goes on about his heroic kitty cat during Armageddon-like mission

— The second and final appearance of Bobby’s Kirby character, a.k.a. the “I miss my little kitty cat” guy.
— Despite only appearing once prior to this, this character of Bobby’s surprisingly gets enthusiastic recognition cheers from the audience as soon as the camera first cuts to him in tonight’s installment.
— Like the last time this character appeared, Bobby has the amazing ability to make this very questionable character and material work for me, despite how unnecessary it feels to do this sketch a second time.
— (*groan*) Yet another instance tonight of Bruce hurting the timing of something by pausing for an awfully long time before delivering one of his lines.
— Also like the last time this character appeared, Kirby’s sudden panicked, emotional outburst when thinking his cat perished is making me laugh (even though it’s just a rehashed gag), though unlike last time, it’s not also making me almost shed a sad tear.
STARS: ***


CENTAURI VODKA
(host) is concerned about the back half of his centaur costume (JOM)

— A very funny brief shot of John Milhiser desperately gasping for air in the one second that Nasim lets his head out of the centaur costume. However, it’s sad that that one-second shot has been the ONLY noteworthy face time John has gotten in a live sketch so far in his SNL tenure. I recall hearing from some people who were familiar with John’s performance style at improv shows that he had a knack for physical comedy, which this sketch is somewhat utilizing, with the jerky, spastic leg movements John’s making in the back of the centaur costume. It’s just too bad his first (of what ends up being only TWO this entire season) noteworthy comedic showcase in a sketch has him hidden from the camera most of the sketch. Also, his chances for doing some good physical comedy in this sketch end up getting cut unexpectedly short, because Bruce…well, you’ll see a little later in this sketch review.
— Hilarious cutaway to Beck as Vin Diesel staring at a wall and then slowly turning his head away from it with a dumb, bewildered look on his face.
— Okay, we need to talk about that ending, folks, because boy, is there an interesting backstory to it. This sketch ends EXTREMELY abruptly and confusingly with Bruce suddenly making a comical exit, dragging John behind him inside the centaur costume, who suddenly goes from making jerky, spastic leg movements (because his character is running out of oxygen) to immediately acting like he’s dead, by making his legs be limp on the floor. As Bruce exits, Nasim comes back into the shot, looks confusedly at the exiting Bruce, then spins around in a lost manner, pauses awkwardly as if she doesn’t know what to do, and then randomly yells “Bruce Jenner…is horrified!” as the camera cuts to an exterior shot of the nightclub this sketch is set in, followed by the audience applauding and the sketch fading to black. Here’s the thing about all of that: the exit that Bruce made was mistakenly WAY TOO EARLY, when he still had minutes of material left to perform in this sketch. In the same John Milhiser interview I previously mentioned in my review of this episode’s Black Ops sketch, John talks about this incident. My memory of what John said is a little fuzzy, and thus, some of the details I’m about to relay might be a little off, but anyway, John explains that Bruce was apparently under the completely wrong impression of when he was supposed to exit this sketch. You see, in the script, after Nasim’s “Bruce Jenner…is horrified!” line, the camera was supposed to cut to Taran as Jenner making a comically horrified face, and then we were supposed to have a few more minutes of material dealing with Bruce (Willis) and John’s characters, with John’s character gradually dying from lack of oxygen, and his legs being seen lifelessly dragging on the floor by the culmination of the sketch (which is why John abruptly makes his legs be limp on the floor during the live version of this sketch’s ending when he realizes Bruce is making his exit way too early). All of that had to get scrapped on the fly because Bruce mistakenly exited the sketch very prematurely. That makes this the SECOND time tonight that Bruce completely fucked up the ending of a sketch. Oh, and you know that part I mentioned from this sketch about Nasim coming back into the shot, looking confusedly at the exiting Bruce, then spinning around in a lost manner, and then pausing awkwardly as if she doesn’t know what to do? She was not acting there, people. That was her GENUINE REACTION to Bruce mistakenly exiting this sketch early. In other words, Bruce botched the ending so badly that it resulted in a true professional like Nasim momentarily dropping character onscreen and physically expressing her genuine confusion (seen in the last above screencap for this sketch) over why the fuck Bruce is exiting the sketch early, leaving Nasim momentarily having no idea what to do next before she decides to go on with her scripted “Bruce Jenner…is horrified!” line that ends up not even getting the intended payoff. Yikes. This whole thing has got to be one of the most (if not THE most) botched sketch endings in SNL history.
— The botched ending of this sketch makes me wonder, did NBC ever re-air this episode? I think I recall hearing they didn’t, but I can’t say for sure. If they didn’t re-air this, I’m assuming it’s because they’re not proud of this episode (backing up that theory of mine is the fact that, according to what I once heard, practically NONE of this episode’s sketches are on YouTube), due to the weak quality of both the episode itself and Bruce’s hosting performance, not to mention all of the gaffes. If they did re-air this, does anyone know if they fixed the botched ending of both this and the Barbershop sketches by showing the dress rehearsal version of those, or did they just leave them unaltered?
STARS: Not even sure I can fairly rate this, given how much of the sketch we missed due to Bruce’s way-too-early exit. If I am supposed to give this a rating, I’ll give it a *½, but I feel bad for that, because if the sketch played out in full like it was supposed to, it most likely would’ve been a pretty good piece that got a decent rating from me.


PROTECTIVE SON
newly-fatherless Eddie mocks his mom’s (VAB) date’s (host) verbal slip-up

— Oh, geez. Look, I could tolerate a sequel to Bobby’s Kirby sketch, but I did NOT need a sequel to Taran’s Eddie sketch, a.k.a. the “glice” sketch, which I was iffy about in its first installment. Man, the writers must’ve been hard up for material this week if they’re resorting to bringing thin-as-hell characters like Kirby and Eddie back. I wonder if SNL intentionally only brings out this Eddie character whenever the show has a bad host (Justin Bieber, Bruce Willis). Well, I guess not, since SNL attempted to do an installment of this sketch when Zach Galifianakis (who is certainly nowhere near being a bad host) hosted the preceding season, but it got cut after dress rehearsal.
— Much like in the Kirby sketch earlier tonight, the audience surprisingly gives Taran’s entrance as Eddie a lot of recognition cheers, despite the fact that he previously only appeared in one sketch.
— “Chun”? That’s not even inherently comical-sounding like “glice” somewhat was. (Neither is “vrest”, for that matter, which was the slip-of-the-tongue word that the aforementioned cut-after-dress Zach Galifianakis installment of this sketch centered around.)
— Bruce, after Taran’s Eddie yells something in his face: “You’re spitting right in my mouth, Eddie.” The way Bruce said that line, I get the feeling it was an ad-lib.
— I like that we actually get continuity from the previous installment of this sketch, by mentioning the father character that Jason Sudeikis previously played, and writing him off in tonight’s installment by explaining he walked out on his family because he was sick of Eddie’s antics.
— Like the last time this sketch appeared, Taran’s doing his damnedest to milk laughs out of this nothing material, but, unlike the last installment of this sketch, there are a lot of moments here where Taran is unfortunately bordering on annoying the living HELL out of me. I know this Eddie character is supposed to be annoying, but he’s supposed to be annoying in a way that makes you laugh. I ain’t laughing. Instead, I’m almost more like how Bruce’s character is unhappily reacting to Eddie.
— Okay, I did get a laugh just now from Eddie tearfully saying Bruce’s character looks like he would take care of him if he were trapped inside a Japanese-named office building.
— Terrible ending.
STARS: *½


SIGMA
fraternity’s beer pong rules value whimsy over getting drunk

— At the very beginning of this, you can hear the SNL Band playing the show to commercial, before abruptly stopping when realizing their mistake. The decision to air this short film in this particular spot of the episode must’ve been made at LITERALLY the last minute (and the SNL Band must not have been notified), presumably because Bruce horribly botching the ending of the Centauri Vodka sketch threw this episode’s schedule out of whack, leaving the people at SNL scrambling to fill the unexpected extra airtime left in the show.
— Glad to see SNL continue to establish Beck and Kyle as SNL’s new short film guys.
— Kyle’s delivery in this is cracking me up so much.
— The convoluted, bizarre beer pong rules are hilarious. I especially love the “custom made baseball cards” one, and the “Chug! Chug! Chug!” bit with the toy train.
— In the preceding episode’s Beck/Kyle short, I praised the fast pacing of the gags within it. Well, that goes double for this, as the gags here come at you at a super rapid-fire speed, and I love that.
STARS: ****½


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Walking On Air”


E-METH
Rerun from 9/28/13. The fact that this is airing in the 10-to-1 slot tonight is yet another sign that SNL is scrambling to fill the unexpected extra airtime left in the show from the botched ending of the Centauri Vodka sketch.


GOODNIGHTS


IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS
— A poor episode, and the two pre-taped shorts were the only standout strong things all night. (Pre-taped shorts being the only standout strong segments in an episode is something I recall sadly going on to be a frequent trait of this season. Hopefully, I’m wrong about that, but we’ll see.) The thing about this episode is that the writing, while definitely bad in certain segments, wasn’t all that bad in some of the things that didn’t work. Some of this episode’s sketches had potential, but were ruined by Bruce Willis’ poor delivery and performances. I remember, earlier in the week this episode originally aired, online SNL fans were nervous about how Bruce would turn out as a host, given his infamous reputation at the time for being completely humorless, grumpy, and difficult to work with on movie sets. While it turns out he occasionally (VERY occasionally) displayed a surprising willingness to get silly and loose in this episode, I did not enjoy him as a host AT ALL in this stint. In addition to the aforementioned two separate instances of him completely fucking up the ending of a sketch, I was also put off by how slow and delayed his timing came off in some sketches (resulting in brief moments of dead air). And in general, I just didn’t find him funny in the slightest. From what I recall of his previous hosting stint in 1989, he wasn’t exactly a laugh riot there either, and I remember I had some issues with his performances in the Wayne’s World and Johnny O’Connor sketches from that episode, and he also made a bad gaffe at one point in the The Man & His Music sketch. However, he certainly didn’t hurt that overall episode anywhere near as much as he did this overall one. It also helped that that 1989 episode didn’t utilize him all that heavily, as there were several live sketches that night that didn’t have him in it, which is something that tonight’s episode would’ve benefited greatly from.


MY PERSONAL CHOICE OF “BEST OF” MOMENTS FOR THIS EPISODE, REPRESENTED WITH SCREENCAPS


RATED SEGMENTS RANKED FROM BEST TO WORST
Sigma
Boy Dance Party
24-Hour Energy For Dating Actresses
NASA Shutdown
Armageddon
Weekend Update
Monologue
The Ol’ Barbershop
Black Ops
Centauri Vodka
Protective Son
The Lady Gaga Show


HOW THIS EPISODE STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING ONE (Miley Cyrus)
a big step down


My full set of screencaps for this episode is here


TOMORROW
Edward Norton

December 10, 2011 – Katy Perry / Robyn (S37 E9)

Segments are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars

ON THE RECORD W/ GRETA VAN SUSTEREN
Donald Trump (DAH) attaches superlatives to his GOP debate

— Another Darrell Hammond cameo as Donald Trump. Meh. Maybe it’s because of more modern times, but for some reason, it’s hard for me to laugh at Darrell’s Trump when looking back at these cameos he makes in this early 2010s era.
— Whaaaaa??? In real life, Trump moderated a GOP debate around this time?!? I can’t even imagine what that must’ve been like. Why the hell don’t I remember that happening?
— They need to stop with the tired gag that Kristen’s Greta Van Susteren always does where she switches from talking out of one corner of her mouth to the other. We don’t need to see that EVERY time Kristen plays Susteren.
— Wow, and this cold opening has ended, without me getting a single laugh during the entire thing. Flat-out bad writing, plain and simple.
STARS: *


MONOLOGUE
sartorial inspirations for host’s music videos like “I Kissed A Girl”

— Decent but somewhat generic humor here with cast members coming out as characters/outfits from Katy Perry’s music videos. At least Bill’s walk-on as a fireworks-burned man is slightly inspired.
— Hmm, an unexpected turn with the homoerotic tension and singing between Kristen’s character and Katy.
STARS: ***


J-POP AMERICA FUN TIME NOW!
(host) heads Hello Kitty appreciation club

— During the opening “Coming up next on Michigan State Campus TV” bit, I got a cheap laugh from the mention of an acapella group being bluntly named The Dickheads.
— This sketch has officially become recurring. It’s also gone from appearing towards the end of the show in its first appearance to now suddenly appearing in the lead-off spot.
— Taran and Vanessa continue to be solid in these roles, and I find the recurring sketch itself to be okay. Like I said last time, I’m not quite as big on this recurring sketch as a lot of people seem to be.
— As usual for this recurring sketch, my biggest laughs in tonight’s installment are coming from Jason’s straight man character. I especially like him being heard yelling an off-camera “He’s Chinese!” when Taran and Vanessa say Yao Ming is Japanese.
— Another good line from Jason: “If there’s such a thing as a loving version of racism, I think you found it.”
STARS: ***


THE APOCALYPSE
eschatological movie is a star-studded romantic comedy

— Some fairly fun returns of good impressions we’ve seen this cast do before, such as Kristen’s Drew Barrymore and Taran’s Ashton Kutcher.
— Funny sudden turn with this jolly New Years Eve-themed movie trailer being revealed as a celebration of the apocalypse.
— Ugh, Fred in drag for the SECOND consecutive segment tonight, even if his Penny Marshall is usually good for a chuckle.
— I got a good laugh from how, during the listing of additional celebrities who will be appearing in this movie, Chris “Ludacris” Bridges is immediately followed by a mention of Kris “Ludacris” Kristofferson.
— I like how some performers are doing multiple celebrity impressions in this.
— A solid Kim Cattrall impression from Kristen.
— During the ending shot of this movie’s actors all being shown saying the movie’s title in unison, Seth, playing himself in a rare non-Weekend Update appearance, can be seen as one of the actors (seen in the bottom right square in the last above screencap). The reason for his appearance is seemingly because he’s in the actual New Years Eve movie that this commercial is spoofing.
— In the aforementioned ending shot of this movie’s actors, you can also see Paul as Osama Bin Laden (seen in the top right square in the last above screencap), despite him not appearing earlier in this movie trailer during any of the actual scenes shown. (Not to mention the fact that Osama’s been dead for half a year by this point.) I don’t know if perhaps a scene with Paul’s Osama got cut from an earlier portion of this commercial, or if him being shown in one of the squares at the end of this commercial was just thrown in as a random joke. Probably the latter.
STARS: ***


KALLE
Kalle’s (KRW) Finnish talk show features extensive clips of host

— Since Katy’s playing herself in this, why in the world is she wearing a wig of her former hairstyle, back when her hair was longer and darker?
— Funny escalation to the absurdity of the clips that Kristen’s Kalle keeps throwing to, and I like how it renders Katy increasingly unsettled. There’s a particularly funny part where, after Katy just says a taken-aback “I…” when she’s at a loss for words, Kalle throws to a quick clip of an eye (Katy’s eye, I’m assuming).
— I wonder if SNL intended this Kalle sketch to become recurring. Whether they did or not, we end up never seeing it return. Probably a good thing, as it seems best left as a funny one-and-done sketch.
STARS: ***½


BEST FRIENDS
ANS & host & addict (Matt Damon) & lunatic (Val Kilmer) & others sing about being besties

— Matt Damon is great as a mentally-disturbed homeless guy suddenly joining Andy and Katy’s jolly Best Friends song, and adding a dark flavor to it. Damon always does a solid job every time I’ve seen him on SNL. (I’ve yet to see the 2018 episode he hosted, though.)
— Now we get a Val Kilmer cameo.
— The sudden and rapid-fire Russian Roulette bit with Damon’s character instantly killing himself was absolutely hilarious, as was Katy responding to that by immediately saying “Okay, f(*bleep*)k this, I’m outta here” and leaving.
— A very funny crazy escalation to the type of people joining in on the Best Friends song, thanks to Kilmer’s time machine.
STARS: ****


DOGGIE DUTY
star-laden soundtrack sidelines canine courtroom movie

— The final appearance of this series of “famous singers do songs for the soundtrack of a fictional animated animal movie” sketches (Bunny Business, Horse Play, and now this). Also, this is the only installment in that series of sketches to NOT air in the 10-to-1 slot. I kinda prefer these sketches in that 10-to-1 slot.
— Also, do we really need two impression showcases tonight and airing so close to each other, with the Apocalypse commercial and now this?
— Why do these always begin with Fred as Randy Newman singing the first song? By this point, that’s beyond played-out.
— Always nice seeing Kristen do a great impression of different 90s singers in each installment of this recurring sketch, though we’ve already seen her play Gwen Stefani elsewhere on SNL.
— Pretty fun dancing from Jason’s Meat Loaf at the end of his scene.
— Meh at the “Remember Spin Doctors?” ending of Andy’s scene as Chris Barron.
— Ha, Bill’s Clint Eastwood!
— A very strong Florence Welch impression from Katy, and I especially like how we’re seeing it just two episodes after Florence + The Machine were a musical guest on SNL. Too bad the writers seemingly forgot to throw any actual JOKES into the song Katy’s Florence is singing here. And that’s how they chose to end this sketch?!?
— Overall, the weakest installment of this recurring sketch. I’m not sorry to see this recurring sketch be retired.
STARS: **


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Call Your Girlfriend”


WEEKEND UPDATE
flirting expert Rebecca Larue (KRW) admits to SEM that she’s just a slut

Alec Baldwin [real] excuses his plane event by posing as a penitent pilot

Stefon offers multiple unsuitable diversions for NYC holiday visitors

— Another new one-off Kristen Wiig Weekend Update character. Sure hope this is better than that god-awful pancake bit Kristen did on Update earlier this season.
— An obvious and simplistic conceit to Kristen’s commentary so far, with her flirting expert character acting very flirtatious towards Seth. However, Kristen’s execution of this is decent enough.
— Kristen’s commentary is getting better as it goes along. The bit she’s doing right now with her legs is particularly funny.
— An Alec Baldwin cameo, spoofing a then-recent incident where he was kicked off a flight for refusing to stop playing Words With Friends on his phone. Ha, something about that incident always tickles me. Something about that incident also seems so on-brand for Alec, given his reputation for having anger issues and an attitude problem. (At least he seems to keep those things in check whenever he’s at SNL.)
— Decent turn with Seth openly calling Alec out on desperately trying to do damage control by posing as the pilot who kicked him off the flight. Alec’s performance is making this pretty fun.
— Stefon continues to grow in popularity, as the cheers his entrance receives from the audience gets wilder with each passing episode he appears in.
— Greatest bits in tonight’s Stefon commentary (and there are even more great bits than usual) are him saying the club password “Diabeetus” in a Wilford Brimley voice, his mention of A Fish Called Kwanzaa, his callback to the club name “SPIIIIICY!” from one of his previous Update commentaries, his mention of Hanukkah cartoon character Menorah the Explorer, and his mention of flaccid outreach group Doctors Without Boners.
— The semi-serious sentimental turn (complete with soft Christmas background music) with Stefon trying to cheer Seth up by promising him a Christmas gift continues the great story arc of the growing dynamic between Seth and Stefon.
STARS: ***


PIPPA VISITS THE QUEEN
Queen Elizabeth (FRA) and Prince Philip (BIH) take liking to similarly-traited Pippa Middleton (host)

— The third and final appearance of this recurring sketch.
— Fred in drag for the THIRD separate segment tonight?!? Are you fucking kidding me?!? Shit like this just adds further fuel to my “Fred needs to finally get his tired self off of SNL” viewpoint. Also, I wonder if this is a record for most times a performer dressed in drag in separate sketches in a single episode.
— The turn in these Royal Family sketches with Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip suddenly speaking brashly and threateningly in crude accents towards their guest has gotten old by this point. However, given the fact that their guest is played by Abby and not SNL’s host (who has yet to appear in this sketch so far), you can tell this sketch must have something new in store for us.
— Bill’s way of saying “Hello, Pip-pa!” in a staccato manner with a high-pitched British accent made me laugh.
— Ugh at Fred hiking up his skirt so high.
— And there’s the new thing this sketch has in store for us, with Katy’s Pippa Middleton actually bonding with Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip by speaking in the same brash, threatening manner with a crude accent. An okay turn, and Katy’s pretty fun here in her performance, but I’m still kinda burned out on this recurring sketch in general.
— Like the last installment of this sketch prior to tonight, the characters do a musical performance at the end of this. I liked it last time, but it’s not as fun this time.
STARS: **½


POLITICS NATION WITH AL SHARPTON
Al Sharpton (KET) butchers words toward the wrong camera

— Kenan’s Al Sharpton impression has improved from the last time he played him, which was surprisingly way back in season 33.
— The premise of Kenan’s Sharpton misreading names, facing the wrong camera, etc. feels kinda cheap (though, reportedly, the actual Politics Nation show that this sketch is spoofing really was gaffe-filled), but I admit that all of these Sharpton gaffes are making me laugh. Kenan’s executing this decently.
STARS: ***


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Dancing On My Own”


ONE MAGICAL NIGHT
at a piano bar, lonely (host) falls hard after meeting her soulmate (BOM)

— Ah, a display of Jason’s great singing voice. That happens astonishingly little during his SNL tenure.
— I’m absolutely loving the structure of this sketch, between all the bizarre interplay between Katy and Bobby, and the interstitial songs from the Jason/Kenan/Fred band. And the execution of this sketch is great.
— I like how increasingly odd the lyrics that Jason’s singing are subtly becoming over the course of this sketch. The song is also VERY catchy.
— Bobby’s reaction to Katy falling down the elevator shaft is absolutely hilarious.
— Overall, an underrated and forgotten gem. This sketch felt so different from the typical style of sketches in this era. I’d love to know who wrote this. Thanks in advance if anyone answers.
STARS: ****½


GOODNIGHTS


IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS
— A very average episode. Not much stood out as great, but most of the show stayed in the passable “just decent” range.


MY PERSONAL CHOICE OF “BEST OF” MOMENTS FOR THIS EPISODE, REPRESENTED WITH SCREENCAPS


RATED SEGMENTS RANKED FROM BEST TO WORST
One Magical Night
Best Friends
Kalle
Weekend Update
The Apocalypse
J-Pop America Fun Time Now!
Politics Nation with Al Sharpton
Monologue
Pippa Visits The Queen
Doggie Duty
On The Record w/ Greta Van Susteren


HOW THIS EPISODE STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING ONE (Steve Buscemi)
a step down


My full set of screencaps for this episode is here


TOMORROW
Jimmy Fallon hosts the Christmas episode

September 25, 2010 – Amy Poehler / Katy Perry (S36 E1)

Segments are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars

RNC HEADQUARTERS
additional closet skeletons imperil Christine O’Donnell’s (KRW) candidacy

— New cast member Vanessa Bayer gets the fairly rare honor of not only appearing in the cold opening of her first episode before she’s even been intro’ed in the opening montage, but she delivers the first big line of the beginning of this cold opening.
— As apparently yet another sign of how popular Kristen is, the audience actually applauds her entrance here.
— The explicit masturbation talk is providing some pretty good laughs.
— Good portrayal of Christine O’Donnell by Kristen.
— A funny “3½ minutes later” title screen being shown onscreen while Kristen’s O’Donnell has left the room to masturbate.
STARS: ***


OPENING MONTAGE
— Same montage from the preceding season.
— The preceding season montage’s and bumpers’ commemoration of SNL’s 35th anniversary has been removed this season.
— Starting with this episode, and lasting for the remainder of his tenure as SNL’s announcer, Don Pardo no longer does his announcements live, and instead tapes it from his hometown, I believe. Something about his taped voice sounds a little oddly mixed with the theme music in tonight’s opening montage.
— Abby Elliott and Bobby Moynihan have been promoted from featured players to repertory players.
— Vanessa Bayer, Paul Brittain, Taran Killam, and Jay Pharoah have all been added to the cast tonight.

— For some inexplicable reason, during the featured players portion of this montage, Nasim Pedrad is credited before Taran Killam, despite the fact that Nasim’s last name alphabetically comes after Taran’s last name. This would later be corrected in all subsequent episodes this season, and, I believe, in reruns of this episode. I guess you can say this episode is the first time in which a category of cast members weren’t listed alphabetically since all the way back in the very first episode.


MONOLOGUE
Justin Timberlake [real], RAD, JIF, TIF inhabit AMP’s preshow stress dream

— Another SNL monologue with a Betty White mention, as Amy Poehler jokingly says that, much like Betty White, she’s 88½ years old.
— Blah at Amy’s reveal that the beautiful boys she’s “had” are Nick Jonas and Taylor Lautner.
— A nice-albeit-jokingly-brief introduction to tonight’s four new cast members.
— During the Twilight Zone-esque montage at the beginning of the dream sequence, they strangely include a photo of Amy’s character from that largely-forgotten Big Wigs sketch from the season 32 Jaime Pressly episode (the third above screencap for this sketch).
— I love the bit with Nasim playing Amy’s Kaitlin’s character.
— Random Justin Timberlake cameo, much to the chagrin of a certain number of SNL fans, I’m sure.
— A great “Poehler Bear/polar bear” bit during Rachel Dratch’s appearance.
— It feels kinda odd seeing all of these appearances from early 2000s female cast members (including tonight’s host, Amy), given the fact that they all had then-recently cameoed in the Betty White episode towards the end of the preceding season.
— A good excuse for Seth to make a rare non-Weekend Update appearance.
— Reportedly, Jimmy Fallon wasn’t in the dress rehearsal version of this monologue. Kinda hard for me to imagine this scene with just Tina Fey bullying Amy, instead of both Tina AND Jimmy bullying Amy.
— Despite this monologue being an absolute cameo-fest, I’m enjoying this, and am finding the whole dream sequence conceit to be fun. Plus, at least all of these cameos are from SNL-related people.
— Hilarious seeing Kenan randomly playing Lorne, a gag that would probably come off less random if it appeared in a more recent episode in the modern-day SNL era.
STARS: ****


BRONX BEAT WITH BETTY AND JODI
busty teen (musical guest) distracts kids at her library gig

— In addition to all the SNL-related cameos in the monologue, particularly from early 2000s female cast members, we now get another one here, with Maya Rudolph.
— The usual funny comments and gripes from Amy and Maya’s Betty and Jodi characters.
— Katy Perry’s cleavage-revealing Elmo shirt is a good subtle(?) reference to her Sesame Street controversy from earlier that week, and it’s taking this recurring sketch into an interesting new direction.
— A lot of great lines from Amy and Maya in reaction to Katy’s physical appearance.
STARS: ****


BOSLEY HAIR RESTORATION
Bosley Hair Restoration fills scalps with transplanted pubic hair

— A cheap laugh from the visual of a scientist extracting pubic hair from a patient.
— Meh, the visuals of various clients with pubic hair transplants on their heads aren’t doing much for me.
— I did get a chuckle from Kristen’s line about still having plenty pubic hair left down there.
— Funny ending visual of Nasim lovingly burying her face into the pubic hair on top of Fred’s head.
STARS: **


MATERNITY MATTERS
Rodger Brush offers chauvinism to expectant mothers

— Oh, no. Not this again.
— As usual, the routine of Fred’s Rodger Brush repeatedly asking his guests to speak up is absolute MISERY.
— “Terry Facials”?
— I did get a laugh from Rodger Brush advising Amy to just get a flowery dress, put on makeup, and tell her husband “I’m sorry, honey, this is whatcha get.”
— Surprisingly, I got another chuckle from a Rodger Brush line just now, when he responds to Andy’s sex-during-pregnancy question by telling him that’s not the first thing Andy’s going to want his baby to see.
STARS: **


MOSQUE AT GROUND ZERO
The Mosque At Ground Zero further affronts with gay weddings & more

— I’m noticing in all her appearances tonight that Vanessa Bayer looks a little different and so young-faced in this debut episode of hers compared to how I remember her looking throughout her SNL tenure.
— I’m iffy about this “gay weddings at the Ground Zero Mosque” premise, as it seems like an excuse for this SNL era to rely on even more lazy gay humor as a crutch, right after a season that already relied a little too heavily on that crutch, but Bill’s performance as the spokesperson is so damn fun that he’s making me enjoy this. Furthering my enjoyment are all the various photos of the cast members.
— An interesting RNC twist ending.
STARS: ***


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “California Gurls”


WEEKEND UPDATE
incredulous SEM & AMP say “Really!?!” to “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy

Will Smith (JAP) exults in the success of his family members

911 call documents (SEM) being attacked by a parrot (AMP)

David Paterson [real] dislikes David Paterson (FRA) goofing on blindness

— Oof, Seth stumbles over his opening joke, causing it to get a tepid audience reaction.
— I see SNL ain’t wasting no time bringing the “Really?!?” segment back, as they break it out only two or three jokes into tonight’s Update. Maybe this is a good thing, given how Seth was kinda struggling with some of his first few jokes.
— Some pretty good comments from Seth and Amy during tonight’s “Really?!?”. I especially like Seth’s comment towards Lady Gaga that “it’s very hard to be the girl in the meat suit on Sunday and the voice of reason on Tuesday.”
— After the “Really?!?” segment ends, Amy casually sticks around by being an unofficial guest co-anchor and doing Update jokes.
— I notice that Seth’s spirits and the quality of tonight’s Update in general both seem to have risen ever since Amy showed up.
— Nice to see Jay Pharoah get a showcase for his celebrity impression skills right in his first episode.
— Even if he’s relying on A LOT of repetitive vocal tics, Jay’s doing the most spot-on Will Smith vocal impression I’ve ever heard. I think I recall Jay later disclosing in an interview that he was told Justin Timberlake, while watching Jay’s Will Smith commentary on a TV monitor in his dressing room, was so impressed by Jay’s Smith impression that he ran out of his dressing room and went around excitedly talking to others backstage about it.
— A pretty fun return of Seth and Amy’s 911 phone call routine from back in the day, where they do the voice of a dispatcher, a caller, and a parrot.
— Fred-as-David-Paterson’s insults are weaker than usual so far tonight.
— Now to hurt my enthusiasm for this Paterson commentary even more, the real David Paterson shows up, turning this into a corny traditional “sneaker-upper” bit, where a celebrity confronts their impersonator.
— The real Paterson gets in a Giuliani-esque lighthearted jab at SNL: “Working in Albany is just like watching Saturday Night Live: there are a lot of characters, it’s funny for 10 minutes, and then you just want it to be over.”
— The real Paterson is at least coming off affable and laid-back here, and seems to be a good sport.
— Much like when she was delivering a sentimental goodbye message to us at the end of the Weekend Update from her final episode as a cast member, Amy’s serious speech about Jeff Zucker stepping down from NBC gets interrupted by both Fred’s Paterson and the real Paterson popping up in front of the camera.
STARS: ***


THE LEAN YEARS
AMP stars as one-legged Amber in a new Showtime program

— Kristen’s bit as Mary-Louise Parker’s Weeds character absolutely BOMBED.
— The return of Amy’s one-legged Amber character.
— I kinda like the format of this sketch, with the typical Amber scenes being interspersed with Showtime interview footage of Amy as herself explaining the Lean Years show that Amy’s Amber character is starring in.
— Meh, the Amber scenes are getting less and less funny as this sketch goes on. The only real comedy seems to be coming from the interview clips of Amy, and even those are only mildly funny.
STARS: **


BOOGERMAN
Boogerman (Peter Sarsgaard) movie song is up for award

— A very interesting and unusual way of presenting this concept.
— Funny visuals of the ridiculous Boogerman musical being performed by Andy and others.
— Pretty fun use of the cast and Amy in individual Boogerman movie clips.
— A very random Peter Sarsgaard cameo as Boogerman in the final movie clip.
— Funny abrupt ending to the awards scene with Bill.
STARS: ***½


LADIES WHO LUNCH
tiny hats allow fashionable Trish (AMP) to one-up jealous Sylvia (KRW)

— I recall there being accusations of plagiarism towards this sketch, but I can’t remember the specifics at all, nor if the accusations turned out to be accurate.
— Even in just a supporting role in her first episode, Vanessa’s already coming off as a total natural and a comforting presence.
— A fairly amusing escalation to the tiny hats gag, with Kristen’s hat now being only visible through a microscope.
— I like the further escalation, with a now microscopic Amy AND Bill appearing on Kristen’s head.
— A laugh from Bill’s “It should’ve been you!” line towards Kristen when he’s mourning Amy’s death.
STARS: ***


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Teenage Dream”


ACTOR II ACTOR
ANS’s music question upsets Justin Timberlake [real]

— Strangely, that’s Maya Rudolph’s voice as the opening announcer.
— An amusing dead-serious demeanor from Andy and Justin at the beginning of the interview.
— Hilarious twist with a serious Andy suddenly asking Justin in a ditzy voice, “When are you gonna make more music???”, which pisses Justin off and leads to him walking off the show, immediately concluding this sketch. Short and sweet.
STARS: ****


THE UNWATCHABLES
sequels to The Expendables feature actors who are available & unwatchable

— This is the type of impression parade that I find fairly fun and worth a few laughs.
— Two spot-on celebrity impressions from Jay in his debut episode.
— I got a very cheap big laugh from the whole Brigitte Nielsen scene with Andy.
— Very funny ending to Kenan’s Tracy Chapman scene, with his Chapman stopping mid-song to admit “I should not be in this movie.”
— A very minor detail, but I like some of the individual greenscreen backgrounds used for the celebrity scenes, especially the one used for the aforementioned Brigitte Nielsen scene.
— The very topical Steven Slater bit with Taran Killam has probably aged poorly among general audiences, because, other than me, I doubt many people today, 10 years after this episode, have any idea who Steven Slater is. Taran at least gets a very good audience reaction for what’s his first noteworthy comedic role on SNL.
— Speaking of Taran, every single role he’s gotten in tonight’s episode (not counting him appearing as himself with the other newbies in the monologue) has been as a gay guy: 1) a photo of him and Paul Brittain as a gay soldier couple in the Mosque At Ground Zero commercial, 2) a lispy effeminate guy in a blink-and-miss-it appearance in one of the Boogerman movie clips, 3) and now Steven Slater. Wow. Quite an odd feat for a cast member in their first episode. I wonder if this holds the record for most gay roles played by a cast member in a single episode. I’m sure that not even Fred or Chris Kattan have equaled that.
STARS: ***


GOODNIGHTS


IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS
— A pretty good season premiere, and I liked most of the segments. Amy Poehler blended back into the cast pretty well, which gave some portions of this episode a refreshing host-less feel.


MY PERSONAL CHOICE OF “BEST OF” MOMENTS FOR THIS EPISODE, REPRESENTED WITH SCREENCAPS


RATED SEGMENTS RANKED FROM BEST TO WORST
Bronx Beat with Betty and Jodi
Actor II Actor
Monologue
Boogerman
RNC Headquarters
The Unwatchables
Mosque At Ground Zero
Weekend Update
Ladies Who Lunch
Bosley Hair Restoration
Maternity Matters
The Lean Years


HOW THIS EPISODE STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING SEASON (2009-10)
a mild step up


My full set of screencaps for this episode is here


TOMORROW
Bryan Cranston