November 10, 1984 – George Carlin / Frankie Goes To Hollywood (S10 E5)

Segments are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars

COLD OPENING
GAK is mad that he wasted time developing a Walter Mondale impersonation

— I liked Gary-as-Mondale’s line “Nobody wants to lose an election by a whisker.”
— Interesting turn with Gary dropping character to complain about how, thanks to Mondale’s recent election loss, Gary already has to retire his Mondale impression after spending all summer working on it.
— Several good lines from Gary here.
— Nice “Live from New York…” variation.
STARS: ***½


MONOLOGUE
after a clip of host’s entrance on the first SNL, he talks about religion

— Very nice touch how this started with a clip of George’s monologue entrance from the very first SNL episode ever. The clip brought back nice memories of when I reviewed that episode back when I first began this project, and it makes me fully realize how far I’ve come along in the project.
— There’s the line “They told me if I did a real good job, they’d have me back”, which would go on to become a go-to line (with variations) for many hosts who return for their second hosting stint after a long time gap
— I like how he’s doing a callback to his controversial God stand-up routine from the first episode, and discusses how it received a complaint.
— Very funny line about how church and state both screw you up bad enough on their own, so “if you put them together, you got certain death”.
— Some good laughs from the “prayer” he’s doing.
— An overall great stand-up monologue as expected.
STARS: ****


NIGHT WATCH
while on patrol, night watchmen Willie & Frankie talk about pain

— This has always been the installment of this recurring sketch that I’ve been most familiar with and the most fond of, as my first viewing of it was my introduction to these characters and I liked them instantly.
— Funny talk about Willie and Frankie being a “stallion” with the ladies.
— I really like the part about pouring tabasco sauce into open foot wounds.
— This installment is even better than these sketches usually are, as some of Willie and Frankie’s descriptions of their masochistic actions are particularly making me both cringe and laugh at the same time.
— There’s Christopher’s “stripped down to the nude” line, which will eventually cause Billy to crack up.
— Yep, there’s Billy’s laughing. This is oddly a strong way to end this sketch.
— Overall, a great installment just like I had remembered.
STARS: ****


THE JOE FRANKLIN SHOW
Jackie Rogers, Jr. (MAS) & Senor Cosa (CHG)

— The debut of a sketch that would go on to be a season 10 staple. I was never all that crazy about these sketches before, but I get the feeling I’ll appreciate them more now.
— Speaking of debuts, this is also the SNL debut of Martin’s hilarious Jackie Rogers Jr. character.
— Nice to see George Carlin will actually be participating in sketches this time, unlike his first hosting stint where he only did stand-up pieces throughout the show.
— Christopher’s Senor Cosa character is cracking me up.
— Funny bit with Billy watching Christopher taking a drink of water in anticipation of seeing a ventriloquist trick, only for it to turn out Christopher’s simply taking a drink of water.
— I love how Jackie Rogers Jr’s book is titled “Damn You Daddy, Sir”.
— George’s details about firemen’s occupational hazards are pretty funny.
— Overall, as I predicted, I enjoyed this sketch more than I used to.
STARS: ***½


THE GHOSTBUSTER SHOW
sisters Chi Chi (MAG) & Consuela (JLD) are big fans

— Feels good to see Jim again for the first time in what feels like a while, after his absence in the last episode.
— More season 10 recurring characters debuting tonight, as we get the first appearance of Chi Chi and Consuela. Not sure if this Ghostbusters talk show is a great setting for them, though.
— I did get a laugh from the rumor about a Ghostbusters sequel starring Tim Matheson and Prince.
— Good characterizations from Mary and Julia here.
— Mary’s lines about how the black Ghostbuster “deedn’t do notheeng” are funny.
— Overall, this contained a few more laughs than I expected, but this still wasn’t too great as a whole.
STARS: **½


YE OLDE COMEDY SHOPPE
stand-up pioneer (host) does 18th century jokes at Ye Olde Comedy Shoppe

— Pretty funny concept of a colonial stand-up comedian.
— Eh, the stand-up jokes themselves aren’t turning out that great, but George’s delivery is making them work fairly well.
— Overall, decent execution of a so-so script.
STARS: ***


NOT A COP
(host) points to family tradition when son (BIC) doesn’t want to be a cop

— Pretty funny examples from Billy of why he’s not good at being a cop.
— I liked George’s “Thank god your mother’s not here to see this… she’s out on patrol” line.
— Billy and George are playing well off of each other here.
— Good ending.
STARS: ***½


TED’S BOOK OF WORLD RECORDS
Ted’s (host) Book Of World Records contains his achievements only

— I really like this, with George listing off some of his unimpressive, strange world records.
— I especially got a good laugh just now from “Most rattlesnakes ever milked: none!”
STARS: ****


PROFILES IN SPORTS
by Claude Kerven- intense chess club coach (JIB)

— Love Jim’s performance as an aggressive, violent Bobby Knight-esque chess coach.
— Great little part with the play that Jim draws on a chalkboard being a chess board, down to him even coloring in the dark squares.
— Hilarious part with a wild brawl breaking out among the coaches and the chess nerds.
— Good ending with Jim at the dinner table making chess-like moves with salt and pepper shakers.
— An overall fantastic film featuring what is possibly Jim Belushi’s most well-known SNL performance.
STARS: ****½


SATURDAY NIGHT NEWS
PLS introduces American men to her large, very agile breasts
host thinks Charlton Heston would make a good GOP candidate in 1988
host cures GAK’s “spot bleeding” condition by reminding him of shirt pins
Lew Goldman gives the sports report for members of his family

— Abrupt transition from George’s jokes to Pamela’s commentary, the latter of which didn’t even begin with the usual applause.
— Rare to hear Pamela speaking in her natural accent.
— Great concept of Pamela introducing us to her breasts.
— LOL at Pamela’s left breast slowly moving up while Pamela’s speaking to the camera.
— Great ending with Pamela’s breasts going completely out-of-control and throwing her over the desk.
— Some funny comparisons from George, between Charlton Heston and Ronald Reagan.
— Gary being introduced as a “science editor” initially made me almost think we were getting another Dr. Jack Badofsky commentary before I remembered Tim Kazurinsky isn’t in the cast anymore.
— Funny reveal that Gary’s “spot bleeding” is simply caused by him forgetting to remove the pins from his new shirt.
— Loved George’s “You’re a moron, Kroeger!” line.
— George is noticeably doing very few jokes between commentaries. Maybe a good thing, as he’s not a great fit for Saturday Night News.
— Haha, what was with an audience member shouting “LEW!! LEW!!” at the beginning of the Lew Goldman commentary?
— I liked Billy’s response to the aforementioned audience member: “Shut up, you idiot!”
— The Lew Goldman sports commentary is a just a variation of his earlier meteorologist commentary. Nothing too exciting here.
STARS: **½


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Two Tribes”


RICH HALL’S ELECTION REPORT
sound bites are mouthed by characters in a cartoon

 

— It’s about time Rich Hall appeared tonight. It’s a shame how underused he often tends to be.
— I love how Rich is using an old Heckle and Jeckle cartoon to represent Reagan/Mondale “footage”, which is pretty funny. As I mentioned in an earlier review, I always like when SNL does stuff like this.
STARS: ***½


STRATEGIC AIRBORNE CONTRACEPTIVE
cold war technology makes the Strategic Airborne Contraceptive possible

— Hilarious concept.
— Good visual of the device lighting up in the dark when detecting the possibility of love-making.
— Another great use of stock footage tonight.
STARS: ****


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Born to Run”


GOODNIGHTS


IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS:
— A very good show, continuing the streak of really solid episodes that started with Jesse Jackson. A lot of tonight’s sketches were above average, and the overall show had a feel that I find very representative of this season as a whole.


HOW THIS EPISODE STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING ONE (Michael McKean):
— about the same


My full set of screencaps for this episode is here


TOMORROW:

Ed Asner

October 11, 1975 – George Carlin / Janis Ian, Billy Preston (S1 E1)

Sketches are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars

WOLVERINES
(JOB) mimics wolverine phrases & heart attack of English teacher (MOD)

— For some reason, I like the kinda-gritty feel of the beginning of this inaugural sketch.
— Ha, all that’s happened so far is John Belushi simply walking down the stairs with a bag of groceries, yet the audience is ALREADY chuckling.
— The disturbing phrases Michael is having John repeat is a hilarious out-of-nowhere reveal.
— It seems fitting that the first sketch Michael O’Donoghue appears in has him acting out an almost-too-realistic heart attack, which is so true to his style.
— A great little touch right before John imitates Michael’s heart attack is this funny puzzled eyebrow raise he does, which is a bit similar to the eyebrow raise that would later become his trademark.
— What better way for SNL to debut than with a bizarre, twisted sketch that let audiences know this wasn’t going to be another Carol Burnett or Laugh-In kind of show?
STARS: ****½

OPENING MONTAGE
— Ah, here we go…
— I, and I’m sure a lot of people, often forget that the show was called “NBC’s Saturday Night” in its early days.
— It’s funny how primitive the theme music sounds in this first episode; it almost sounds like it’s being played inside a cardboard box. Even in other early Season 1 episodes I remember seeing before, the sound quality is definitely better.
— Ah, Pardo’s famous “Not For Ready Prime-Time Players” flub. It sounds like he himself realized his mistake as soon as he said it.
— Another thing I often forget about these early episodes is that the cast members weren’t announced one-by-one accompanied with a picture/clip of them, but were announced collectively as just “The Not Ready For Prime-Time Players” accompanied by a quickly-shown list of their names. And in this first episode, the list of their names isn’t even in alphabetical order, either:

— And let’s not forget that George Coe and Michael O’Donoghue were actually part of the cast early on. Those two only last for a very small handful of episodes (not sure how many exactly) before being taken out of the cast and making non-credited appearances. The fact that they’re the bottom two credited in this episode’s cast list makes me wonder if it was ALREADY planned for their stay in the cast to be short-lived.

MONOLOGUE
host does stand-up about football & baseball terminology differences
 
— So unusual to see the host making their entrance through the audience instead of through the ‘basement’ set that would soon become the familiar homebase stage of the early seasons.
— I like his little comments at the beginning about the novelty of this being a live TV show.
— This football/baseball routine is different from the type of stand-up I’m used to seeing from him, but I still like it (especially considering I’ve always liked football and hated baseball). His delivery is helping sell this routine.
— Oddly, at the very end, as the audience is applauding, the band replays the opening theme music for a bit before we go to the next segment.
STARS: ***½

NEW DAD INSURANCE
New Dad insurance covers all your family’s needs, not just financial ones
 
— Hard for me to believe that Dan Aykroyd was only 23 at this time. I think what makes him seem older is the combo of the mustache and his mature demeanor.
— Oh, that’s right, SNL didn’t mix in the audience reactions during the pre-taped segments in these early episodes. It feels so unusual hearing silence during the parts of this commercial that you’d expect to get a laugh.
— A pretty funny premise, and the execution was okay.
STARS: ***

MUSICAL PERFORMANCE (BILLY PRESTON)

THE COURTROOM
sleeping juror (GIR) interprets a piece of evidence as a pick-up line


— Garrett’s accent is pretty funny.
— Gilda’s reaction to the note was great.
— And hey, they ended the sketch right there. I love the simple “set-up/punchline” quick structure of this.
STARS: ****

ANDY KAUFMAN
Andy Kaufman [real] lip-syncs the Mighty Mouse theme song
 
— Oh, yes. As a huge Andy Kaufman fan, this classic Mighty Mouse routine has always been one of my all-time favorite things on SNL ever, and also my #1 favorite thing Kaufman ever did anywhere.
— In addition to the main joke of him only lipsyncing to that one key lyric, there’s a lot of little things he does that helps makes this so great, such as 1) the awkward beginning where there’s just dead air as he nervously stands there for a while before turning the record player on, 2) the brief close-up of him about to lipsync to the wrong part before realizing his mistake and then looking down in shame, and 3) the way you can see him visibly getting prepared to raise his arm & lipsync every time the key lyric is about to come up.
— The water-drinking bit during the song’s long instrumental break is another classic part.
STARS: *****

(SIDE NOTE: The post-commercial bumper pictures in this episode just show still shots of NYC nightlife, instead of a picture of the host like we’re used to seeing)

GEORGE CARLIN STAND-UP #2
host does observational stand-up about many different topics

— Love the line about looking at the crowds in old movies and wondering if they’re dead yet.
— I’m really enjoying the loose structure of this, jumping from one quick random topic to another, which is my favorite type of stand-up comedy.
— The ‘there’s a moment coming, it’s on the way, here it i— aw, it’s gone’ bit was fantastic.
STARS: ****

MUSICAL PERFORMANCE (JANIS IAN)

VICTIMS OF SHARK BITE
(JOB) falsely claims to have had limbs bitten off
 
— Hmm, an opening graphic of a shark. Are we getting our very first Landshark ske– oh, wait, I see from the title that just showed up that this is something different.
— Jane plays her first of what I remember being MANY talk show hosts over the next few seasons.
— Wow, another quick sketch. This was a nice, simple bit that got out before anything could get too one-note.
STARS: ***

JAMITOL
CHC describes how Jamitol allows his wife MOD to be productive

— Ohh, boy. This hasn’t aged very well, as the idea of a commercial testimonial featuring a same-sex couple isn’t as unusual or funny nowadays as it was in the 70s.
— It still is fairly amusing to see Michael O’Donoghue of all people saying sensitive woman lines that the wives in these commercial testimonials usually gets.
STARS: **

NEXT WEEK PROMO
Paul Simon [real] announces he’ll be hosting SNL next week

— Not gonna rate this, obviously, but it is interesting to see the “next week promo” being done with an appearance by that episode’s host instead of it just being a bumper stating the upcoming host and musical guest’s names.

WEEKEND UPDATE, PART 1
LAN reports from the Blaine Hotel on its latest murder victim
   
— Wow, right from the very first episode, we get Chevy’s trademark “phone conversation” opening gag, which I wasn’t expecting so soon.
— Hmm, no “I’m Chevy Chase and you’re not” intro, which I WAS expecting.
— Did Chevy look into the wrong camera during that one news story just now?
— I was right, he did it again in the next news story… or are the camera people the ones that messed up?
— Ah, and now he acknowledged the camera screw-ups by jokingly looking back-and-forth between both cameras quickly.
— Oh, the famous prostitution stamp joke was in THIS episode? For some reason, I always thought it was a little later this season. Anyway, we can pinpoint this as the very first time an Update joke ever got a HUGE audience reaction.
— Hey, it’s Laraine. I believe this is the first time all night we’ve seen her, which is strange since the show’s halfway over and all the other cast members already made their first appearance much earlier.
— A “still to come” news bit? I guess this is one of those early Updates that has a break in the middle for a fake ad.

TRIOPENIN
a child-proof safety cap makes Triopenin arthritis medicine unobtainable

— I was right.
— The ‘hand acting’ from the unseen actor was good. The frustrated attempts to open the bottle was nice and subtle.
STARS: ***

WEEKEND UPDATE, PART 2
 
— The ‘guests stay at the Blaine Hotel’ ad was a hilarious callback to earlier.
— The baby sandpiper story had a great dark ending after such a long set-up.
— Strong way to end the first Weekend Update.
STARS: ***

JIM HENSON’S MUPPETS
Ploobis (Jim Henson) & Scred (Jerry Nelson) visit Mighty Favog (Frank Oz)
 
— Oh, boy, here we are, the infamous Muppets from Season 1.
— I surprisingly kinda like the voices of these puppets, especially the one for Ploobis’ wife.
— What hideous puppets, though. All of them.
— Some of these lines are actually kinda making me laugh, especially the “massage your moogies” line from Scred.
— Was it intentional for the food deliverer puppet to have trouble letting go of Ploobis’ meal, or was that a real blooper?
— Some of these jokes are pretty corny.
— Wow, that “cheer up, things could be worse” punchline was awful.
— And that’s the joke they end this sketch with? Oh, man. I was actually kinda enjoying some of the humor of this sketch early on, but the last two minutes was pretty bad and made me start to kinda understand why these Muppets segments would go on to be so hated.
STARS: **

GEORGE CARLIN STAND-UP #3
host does stand-up about blue food, vitamins, oxymorons

— This is when you start to realize that he hasn’t appeared in any actual sketches at all tonight; just these solo stand-up pieces on the homebase stage. This is just one of the many unusual aspects of this first episode.
— Love his “Have I done these jokes before tonight?” ad-lib after the jokes started getting a tepid reaction.
— The “why is there no blue food” bit is both very funny and a great point.
— This is another ‘one quick random topic after another’ stand-up bit, which once again is something I always enjoy.
STARS: ****½

A FILM BY ALBERT BROOKS
“The Impossible Truth”- newsreel reports unlikely items
 
— The blind cab driver looks familiar for some reason. Maybe he just reminds me of someone.
— I haven’t been laughing much yet, but I do always like ‘alternate universe’-type premises like this.
— The “I can’t read yet” line from the little girl in the ‘age of consent lowered to age 7’ scene was pretty funny, though aren’t most kids able to read by that age?
— Overall, not bad.
STARS: ***

BEE HOSPITAL
new fathers find out where their offspring rank in the hive
 
— Well, we may not have gotten a Landshark debut in this episode like I falsely thought earlier, but we DO get the debut of another staple of 70s SNL: the bees.
— Feels odd seeing Coe and O’Donoghue paired with the rest of the male cast.
— Eh, not really liking the humor here much. Cheesy jokes like this can sometimes work, but I think I had my fill of that type of humor after sitting through the Muppets earlier.
— This didn’t overstay its welcome, though. This was yet another short sketch tonight. I don’t think there’s been a sketch with the cast that was over two minutes long so far.
STARS: **

ACADEMY OF BETTER CAREERS
call Academy of Better Careers now to become a stand-by operator
 
— Wow, yet another pre-taped fake ad tonight.
— There’s the wife from the New Dad commercial again. I think I remember hearing she was Chevy’s girlfriend at the time.
— I like the “not affiliated with the American Broadcast Company” disclaimer that comes up every time ABC is mentioned.
— Overall, this was just okay.
STARS: ***

VALRI BROMFIELD
Valri Bromfield [real] portrays teacher, high school volleyball player

— Well, this feels strange to see on SNL.
— Not caring much for this teacher routine, though some people in the audience are absolutely loving it.
— She sure has energy, though.
— And now she’s suddenly doing ANOTHER character? Ehhh…….
STARS: **

SHOW US YOUR GUNS
SNL goes to the streets to view citizens’ firearms
 
— Unlike some of the other pre-taped segments in this episode, this is a bit that still holds up surprisingly well. SNL even did a fake ad recently in 2015 that can be considered the spiritual successor to this.
— This has some really good little gags thrown in, like the angry store clerk who’s about to shoot at two robbers but then stops to happily wave at the camera, and the traffic cop finding out his gun’s missing and then just shrugging it off.
STARS: ****

GEORGE CARLIN STAND-UP #4
host does stand-up about the relationship between God, man, religion

— While I was really digging the ‘random quick topics’ format of his last two stand-up pieces tonight, THIS is more the George Carlin stand-up that I’m used to seeing.
— Just now, you could see the musical guest stage for Billy Preston light up in the background behind Carlin, before dimming back down again. I’m guessing we weren’t supposed to notice that. Heh, for some reason, I’m getting a kick out of seeing little errors like that in this first episode; it adds to the charm of these early, primitive SNLs.
— I’m loving this whole religion routine.
STARS: ****½

MUSICAL PERFORMANCE (BILLY PRESTON)

TROJAN HORSE HOME SECURITY
(DAA) breaks into house of (JOB) & (GIR) to show need for home security
 
— Wow, I love the concept of this sketch.
— Dan is absolutely PERFECT here. Our first glimpse of his knack for playing pitchmen/salesmen.
— While it was just a throwaway joke, I love the concept of a “toilet bowl piranha” to scare away burglars. That sounds like something that could be a fake SNL ad in itself.
— It feels strange seeing an actual normal-length, fleshed-out sketch tonight, after having so many quick “blackout gag”-type sketches earlier.
— Great bit with John suddenly getting shot at from the back and he reacts in absolute horror, only for it to be revealed the gun was shooting blanks.
— Excellent ending.
STARS: ****

TRIPLE-TRAC
gullible people will appreciate the Triple-Trac shaver’s tricky bladework
 
— I mentioned that the Jamitol commercial earlier hasn’t aged very well, but THIS takes the cake. The then-ridiculous idea of a three-blade razor would later become a case of “life imitates art”, and it’s now considered so normal to use that type of razor that it can be hard to understand what the intended humor of this ad was. If you showed this fake ad to someone without telling them it’s from SNL, they’d most likely think it was a real commercial (which would also be supported by the fact that, again, there were no audience sounds mixed in these early pre-taped segments).
— I did get a laugh from the “Because you’ll believe anything” tagline at the end, which is funny nowadays in an ironic way.
STARS: N/A, because I don’t feel I can fairly rate this nowadays

MUSICAL PERFORMANCE (JANIS IAN)

GOODNIGHTS
 
— Adding to the already-long list of unusual things about this episode is that Carlin is by himself on stage during these goodnights, with no cast members, musical guests, special guests, or anyone else.
— Ah, the familiar goodnights music – one of the things about SNL that hasn’t changed after all these decades (aside from Season 6). In a way, hearing that music in this episode really makes me appreciate the history of the show.
— Every name in the ending credits scroll has the nickname “Bud”. Inside joke? Or was that intended to be the start of a weekly tradition where the ending credits scroll would always have a different gag each time? If so, it’s too bad it never took off.

_______________________________

IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS:
— Wow! Well, there it was, the very first SNL ever.
— This was such a fascination to watch, not just because we now know the still-active institution it would become, but also in how primitive everything about the show felt, in how unusual a lot of things about the show were compared to what we’re used to today, and how probably nobody we saw performing in the show knew what an important part of TV history this episode would later be looked back as. Who would’ve guessed back then that this was a program that would still be running 43 years later?
— To me, the most unusual, uncharacteristic aspect of this episode was the “variety show” feel it had. Instead of focusing mainly on sketches like we’re used to seeing from SNL, this episode was jam-packed with everything from sketches, many musical performances, many stand-up performances, many pre-taped segments, and even a puppetry segment. I’m not used to having to review so many segments in a single episode. It’s been said some places that this episode has the highest number of pieces an SNL episode has ever had. From what I saw, that very well may be true, though I know it was common for the early seasons in general to have a lot of pieces per episode.
— The short length of most of the live sketches was refreshingly surprising, which is something I wish became a long-standing SNL tradition that continued to this day. I wonder at what point in the show’s history did they start to gain their bad reputation for doing overlong one-joke sketches. I guess we’ll see as we go along.
— Excluding George Coe (who ALREADY seems like an outsider among the cast), most of the cast seemed to get a fairly equal amount of airtime for the most part, though I can’t help but feel Laraine kinda got the short end of the stick. Unsurprisingly, Chevy had the most prominent presence.

My full set of screencaps for this episode is here

TOMORROW:
— (sigh) If you know your SNL history, you’ll know that the next episode is going to be a very weird one to review, as it consists almost entirely of nothing but musical performances, with very few comedy pieces. Since I don’t review musical performances, that will possibly end up being my shortest episode review ever in this ‘One SNL a Day’ project.